No... Not a Monster!

Friday, January 29, 2010 1:59 PM | Claire (Administrator)

I am a breastfeeding mom -- and proud of it! I know the benefits of breastfeeding and was lucky enough to have been given all of the support and resources that I needed to help me breastfeed successfully. I was lucky, and I hope that other moms will be just as lucky in having all of the support and resources that they need as well. I support breastfeeding and believe that there is nothing better for our babies.

Are you a breastfeeding mom?  Have you ever stopped to wonder why the "formula feeding mom" next you isn't breastfeeding?

Was it by choice, or could it be due to a lack of knowledge about breastfeeding? Could it be that she didn't have the resources or the support that she needed? Does she have an underlying health problem that makes it unsafe for her to breastfeed?
Maybe she tried various methods, but was unsuccessful. Maybe her doctor told her that she couldn't breastfeed due to health reasons. Maybe she has a condition that makes it impossible to breastfeed.

These are all very real reasons why some moms, unfortunately, are not able to breastfeed successfully.


The story that hurt my heart is of one mom who tried everything to nurse: she saw the lactation consultants, she tried pumping, and she went to clinics. Nothing worked. This mom was also suffering from Postpartum Isolation, loneliness and depression. One day, she walked into a room and started feeding her baby and was called a "MONSTER!"

Why? Because she was formula feeding.  
Was that fair?  Should we do this to our fellow mothers just because they are not as lucky as we are? 

When we see another mom bottle feeding, would it not be more helpful to give that mom some support? To tell her about the benefits of nursing, and try to find out her reasons for why she was not successful? Shouldn't we give her more resources, and point her in the direction of what worked for those of us who are successful?   Maybe she was not aware of the breastfeeding clinics available, or maybe she didn't know about some of the breastfeeding myths out there.

Would it not be more effective to encourage this mom to try harder next time, if she has a second child, by being supportive instead of resorting to name calling, judgment and criticism?  

If you are not sure how to broach the topic, you can use these Three Easy Steps to Discussing Breastfeeding, an adaptation of Best Start’s Three-Step Counseling Program©:
Step 1: Ask open-ended questions about breastfeeding.
Step 2: Affirm the mother’s feelings.
Step 3: Share appropriate information and refer mother to a breastfeeding expert.
For more information on the steps, visit www.beststart.org/courses
 
It’s sometimes easy for us to feel that we are better than other mothers just because we breastfeed. But motherhood is not a competition – it’s a sisterhood!

So let’s stop the judging. Yes, breastfeeding is superior, by far, to formula – there is no comparison. But a breastfeeding mom is not better than a formula feeding mom.
We should all make a conscious decision to be more empathetic towards our fellow mothers. Remember, most of the time, we do not know why a mother isn't breastfeeding, and she may have a very good reason. So let’s not make assumptions anymore.
Parenting is challenging enough without feeling like we have to compete with each other. 

-Claire

Comments

  • Tuesday, February 02, 2010 8:49 AM | Joanna
    Well said! And great advice. I am a breastfeeding mom as well-- I feel so strongly about keeping my children away from formula that I transitioned my first child to goat milk while occasionally breastfeeding rather than switch to formula.

    Just before I gave birth to my first child, I must admit I was pretty judgmental against those who formula fed, and I have met enough moms who didn't even try to breastfeed or believed formula was superior. And then I met a couple of moms who had the most difficult time attempting to breastfeed-- they suffered from physical pain and all sorts of complications, as well as latching problems from their babies. I'm happy to say both moms eventually found the professional help they needed and successfully breastfed their kids. However, after hearing their stories, I'm not sure I could have persevered like they did. So yes, let's try not to pass immediate judgment; let's all be supportive of each other.
    Link  •  Reply
  • Thursday, February 11, 2010 4:00 AM | Deleted user
    I am not a breastfeeding mom. I tried everything and I wasn't able to produce any milk. Well I did produce, 1 oz a day, and that wasn't cutting it for the little one.
    Personally, I rather someone not come up to me and ask me why I am not breastfeeding or try to provide me with breastfeeding clinic informaiton. In this day and age, most women know how to do their research on the internet and can ask their doctors or midwives for help.
    I think that if someone wants to breastfeed they will do it, and if they don't it is their choice. I don't think anyone, woman or man has the right to impose their views on others. This also hold true on the other side, I don't think formula feeding moms should look starangely at breast feeding moms. It is a choice and in the end, you know what is good for your baby.
    Link  •  Reply
    • Thursday, February 11, 2010 5:22 PM | Claire (Administrator)
      Hi Adrienne,
      Thanks for your comment.
      You are absolutely right, the choice of how to feed our babies is a personal choice and that choice should be respected. The advice given above is aimed at people who have a tendency to go up to a bottle feeding mom and put them down and make them feel bad about themselves. If someone really feels the need to make a comment about a mom's feeding choice, they can follow the steps above so that the experience is positive - of course sometimes the old adage of "if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all" applies :-)
      Link  •  Reply
  • Thursday, February 18, 2010 11:34 AM | Deleted user
    Label jars not people. And as I've always told my kids, there's no such thing as monsters. Hey, that could be a good title for this article. :D
    Link  •  Reply

Our Community

Life With A Baby
LWAB Foundation

Our Partners







Click here to visit this Mount Sinai's website

© 2020 Life with A Baby, Inc. All Rights Reserved.